Telecaster shopping, opinions invited

BraylonJennings

It's all blues
A friend opened a new guitar shop locally, so I did some looking at telecasters. I have the raptorcaster, but it's basically a Les Paul in telecaster clothing, so I'm thinking about adding the real deal to my collection. Some of the guitars I tried out are:

G&L tribute- it's a thin line style with a neck HB. Good feeling neck, beautiful sunburst with rosewood board. I'm leaning towards a standard two single coil version. Chinese made.

Fender Performer series- US made, light, plays well. Yosemite pickups, jumbo frets. Fine guitar.

Fender Professional II- US made, plays great. Tall thin fretwire. Slightly thicker neck with rolled edges. Upgraded single coils. Better contoured neck heel.

Reverend Eastsider- an Ohio company but built overseas then set up in US, like a PRS SE. Really plays and sounds great, but about same $$ as the Performer. I'm down to one American made electric, will probably make it two, all other stuff being equal.

Reverend Gristlecaster- the Greg Koch sig model. Great electronics and pickups. I didn't care for the playing feel of the one I tried. Koch is 6ft 7inches, guitar is built 10% bigger. Even weight relieved, this is a big instrument.

Various Squires- didn't really find one I bonded with, but they are mostly acceptable guitars. Nothing wrong with Squires, but I'll probably go with California built for better frets and hardware if I go Fender

G&L Placentia tele- the only truly awful guitar I picked up. A level below the Tribute, I suppose, it had such poor fretwork I might injure myself if I played it much. Owner says all Placentias are like this. Beware, I remember someone discussing these on the forum.

I'm generally a rosewood or ebony fretboard kind of guy, but I could make an exception for a Telecaster as maple is part of the tele experience. I didn't plug in anything but the Reverends. I'm leaning towards one of the California Telecasters and will run them through an amp next time. Decision will be based on playing feel, pickup sounds, and weight.

Any suggestions or things to watch for will be appreciated.
 

MarkDyson

Blues Hound Wannabe
My feeling is some of the best bang for your Tele bucks is the Fender Player II series. Lots of varied styles, including some with rosewood fretboards, some with chambered bodies...quite a selection. Most (or all) come in just under or over US$800. Here's a representative search on Sweetwater for reference:


Mine is a tuxedo model with maple fretboard (and not chambered, so it's a little heavy) and I've become rather fond of it. It was at my local shop so I had a chance to sit down and bond with it before I pulled the trigger.

tele player II 18dec2024.jpeg
 

Elio

Student Of The Blues
A friend opened a new guitar shop locally, so I did some looking at telecasters. I have the raptorcaster, but it's basically a Les Paul in telecaster clothing, so I'm thinking about adding the real deal to my collection. Some of the guitars I tried out are:

G&L tribute- it's a thin line style with a neck HB. Good feeling neck, beautiful sunburst with rosewood board. I'm leaning towards a standard two single coil version. Chinese made.

Fender Performer series- US made, light, plays well. Yosemite pickups, jumbo frets. Fine guitar.

Fender Professional II- US made, plays great. Tall thin fretwire. Slightly thicker neck with rolled edges. Upgraded single coils. Better contoured neck heel.

Reverend Eastsider- an Ohio company but built overseas then set up in US, like a PRS SE. Really plays and sounds great, but about same $$ as the Performer. I'm down to one American made electric, will probably make it two, all other stuff being equal.

Reverend Gristlecaster- the Greg Koch sig model. Great electronics and pickups. I didn't care for the playing feel of the one I tried. Koch is 6ft 7inches, guitar is built 10% bigger. Even weight relieved, this is a big instrument.

Various Squires- didn't really find one I bonded with, but they are mostly acceptable guitars. Nothing wrong with Squires, but I'll probably go with California built for better frets and hardware if I go Fender

G&L Placentia tele- the only truly awful guitar I picked up. A level below the Tribute, I suppose, it had such poor fretwork I might injure myself if I played it much. Owner says all Placentias are like this. Beware, I remember someone discussing these on the forum.

I'm generally a rosewood or ebony fretboard kind of guy, but I could make an exception for a Telecaster as maple is part of the tele experience. I didn't plug in anything but the Reverends. I'm leaning towards one of the California Telecasters and will run them through an amp next time. Decision will be based on playing feel, pickup sounds, and weight.

Any suggestions or things to watch for will be appreciated.
My understanding is that the G&L Placentia's are made in China while the Tributes are made in the Cort factory in Indonesia. It seems as though the Placentia line really seems to get a lot of really bad reviews with respect to quality issues. With that said, I have an Indonesian-made Tribute ASAT Carved Top, which is a really nice playing guitar, lightweight, and super comfortable, although not in any way a traditional tele style.
 

PapaRaptor

Director of Curmudgeonry
Staff member
I have thinned my herd quite a bit and I don't have anything that was made in the last 10 years.
I've had a few MIM Telecasters and one US built Tele, which is an American Special from around 2010 in addition to some of the partscasters I've built. Slab body or contours, 3 saddle bridge or 6. It's strictly whatever feels best to you. Just make sure you turn the control plate around. Fender has been putting them on wrong since the 50's!
 

Liam

Blues 'R' Fun
I have a Performer SH I bought new in 2022 for more than you quoted for your friend's. The Yosemite pups are not as strong as either single coil on my G&L ASAT Tribute. First thing I noticed about the G&L was fret sprouts. After dressing them, the feel was much more comfortable. I tend to play the Performer more than any other just bcause it is handy and I like the feel. I wasn't a big fan of the white pick guard and changed it.

@PapaRaptor why do you say Fender has been putting the control plate on wrong since the '50s?
 

JonMiller216

I'm a Pig Meat Man
Last summer I sprung for the Ultra Tele, just before Fender released the Ultra II, which doesn’t seem to be significantly different. I love everything about it, the noiseless pickups, the 6-Saddle bridge with chromed brass saddles, the compound radius neck and ebony fretboard, the locking tuners, contoured body, and everything else. I can find no fault with the guitar at all, it’s comfortable, well-crafted, and fun to play. I wouldn’t change a thing about as it seems to be an all-around version of the Telecaster.

That being said, I have a Raptorcaster myself, with some nicely hot Quarter Pound pickups. It’s actually the guitar I play the most, mostly because I don’t keep it in a case and it’s just so doggone fun to play. It’s a little more primitive, but it does have the control plate properly installed. ;) Only change I’ve made to it was locking tuners.

The Ultra is more refined and more “all-around”, the Raptorcaster a little more raw. Which one to I like the best? Tough question to answer, glad I don’t have to choose. I will say that I can play a little faster and smoother on the Ultra, but as with all guitars, you have to play them to appreciate them for what they are (and aren’t).

I have a bias about Telecasters that suggests that Leo Fender got it perfect right out of the gate.

I also have a Sire T7FM with splittable humbuckers which I’m quite fond of as well. I could easily recommend the Sire to anyone/everyone. The bang for the buck on the Sire is off the charts.

BTW, Chicago Music Exchange still has the store exclusive Ultra I bought, I got it for considerably less, so they’d probably dicker.

 

BraylonJennings

It's all blues
My understanding is that the G&L Placentia's are made in China while the Tributes are made in the Cort factory in Indonesia. It seems as though the Placentia line really seems to get a lot of really bad reviews with respect to quality issues. With that said, I have an Indonesian-made Tribute ASAT Carved Top, which is a really nice playing guitar, lightweight, and super comfortable, although not in any way a traditional tele style.
I have two US G&L's and they are great guitars. My Legacy strat was my #1 for a long time and still gets played a ton. The Tributes I've tried are great, too. I thought a tribute asat might be in my future. The Legacy ASATs go about $2K, but the Fenders were excellent and cheaper. I have some thinkin' to do. I feel a PRS SE version of their tele is due this year, but I'm leaning towards a classic version, single coils, maple board. Full Roy Buchanan.
Like Rancid used to say, the sound's in the pickups, but neck feel and comfort is just as important.
 

BraylonJennings

It's all blues
I have thinned my herd quite a bit and I don't have anything that was made in the last 10 years.
I've had a few MIM Telecasters and one US built Tele, which is an American Special from around 2010 in addition to some of the partscasters I've built. Slab body or contours, 3 saddle bridge or 6. It's strictly whatever feels best to you. Just make sure you turn the control plate around. Fender has been putting them on wrong since the 50's!
Leo was a stubborn guy. The three barrel bridge seems weird, but 70 years of success must mean something.

My Raptorcaster doesn't even have a control plate. But I'll switch the new one. I don't do big volume swells but I like to control amp distortion with the volume knobs so I'd like it handy.
 

PapaRaptor

Director of Curmudgeonry
Staff member
@PapaRaptor why do you say Fender has been putting the control plate on wrong since the '50s?
Because I've had to turn around the control plates on every Telecaster I've owned! Having the pickup switch right under your picking hand is an open invitation to accidentally changing pickups while in a heated riff.
Also, I fiddle with the volume control much more frequently than the pickup switch.
 

Elio

Student Of The Blues
I have two US G&L's and they are great guitars. My Legacy strat was my #1 for a long time and still gets played a ton. The Tributes I've tried are great, too. I thought a tribute asat might be in my future. The Legacy ASATs go about $2K, but the Fenders were excellent and cheaper. I have some thinkin' to do. I feel a PRS SE version of their tele is due this year, but I'm leaning towards a classic version, single coils, maple board. Full Roy Buchanan.
Like Rancid used to say, the sound's in the pickups, but neck feel and comfort is just as important.

Well, at the risk at throwing one more option into the mix, here is my favorite tele. It's a Michael Kelly CC50 Fralin Custom Collection Edition in striped ebony. I've had mine about 8 years, and it has gone to just about every BGU related event I've been to. The Custom Collection guitars are upgraded in the U.S. with pots, wiring mods, and pickup upgrades. The wiring mod on mine includes a push-pull pot with phase reversal. I don't use it often, but it's a neat effect, when appropriate. This one comes with Lindy Fralin Steel Pole 43 single-coils, which are fairly hot, but work beautifully with the tele-style. I remembered that when I first got it, I posted about here and included some sound clips, although my playing was a bit cringey, but the link is below.


 

PapaBear

Guit Fiddlier
My understanding is that the G&L Placentia's are made in China while the Tributes are made in the Cort factory in Indonesia. It seems as though the Placentia line really seems to get a lot of really bad reviews with respect to quality issues. With that said, I have an Indonesian-made Tribute ASAT Carved Top, which is a really nice playing guitar, lightweight, and super comfortable, although not in any way a traditional tele style.
I have one of those as well, it's a nice guitar, but doesn't scratch my Tele itch.
 

cowboy

Blues, Booze & BBQ
I own a few and have played a ton...my .02...wait till you find one where the neck just "feels" right in your hands...then it's time to pull out your wallet...try to use your hands and ears and not your eyes...I have 5 tele's and only one is a Fender (it's not my favorite)...later.

cowboy
 

straightblues

Blues Junior
Teles are great guitars . I would recommend getting a Tele with two single coils and a 3 barrel saddle like the early ones. Buy it used. Play if for awhile and see if you can bond with it. If you can't, or are looking for something else, then you will know. There are some many variations on the Tele theme available.

I think Fender got it right from the beginning. They are such iconic guitars with such a great voice. Embrace them along with all of their quirks.
 
Top